Why Your Gas Grill Will Never Taste as Good as Charcoal (Unless You Do This) 🔥

Beef | Pork | Poultry | Seafood | Lamb | Shop

Hey there Reader,

Here's something that's been driving us crazy for years. Every time someone mentions gas grills, there's always that one person who says "real pitmasters only use charcoal" or "gas grills don't give real BBQ flavor." 🙄

Here's the thing... they're partially right. But they're also missing the bigger picture.

Look, charcoal's great - if you've got the time, patience, and a bag of briquets on hand. But most folks fire up gas grills for a reason: it’s fast, easy, and gets the job done. The knock? That it just doesn’t deliver the same smoky flavor.

But here’s the truth: your gas grill can produce deep, smoky flavor - if you know how to use wood chips the right way.

The Truth About Gas VS. Charcoal Flavor

Gas grills burn clean. Really clean. So clean that they produce virtually no smoke on their own. Quality charcoal burns clean, too, but it's made from wood, so it still carries those real wood flavors that gas can't provide.

But here's what those charcoal purists don't want to admit: the best smoke flavor comes from wood, not charcoal. Yes, quality lump charcoal and briquets add flavor. But that signature BBQ taste everyone's chasing? That comes from the smoking wood you add.

And here's the kicker 🤫 – your gas grill can produce genuinely great smoke flavor. Will it be as robust as a traditional charcoal setup? No. But it can be surprisingly close, and way better than most people think possible.

The Wood Chip Myth We're Totally Busting

We've been using this technique for over a decade, and it transforms any gas grill into a smoke-producing machine. You don't need expensive equipment, just dry wood chips and something to hold them.

The big secret? Use dry wood chips, not soaked ones.

Most people soak their chips thinking it creates more smoke. Wrong. Soaked chips create steam, not smoke. You want those chips to catch fire and smolder – that's where the magic happens.

You can use a smoker box if you have one, but a simple foil packet works just as well. Even a small aluminum tray with foil poked with holes does the trick. The key is getting those dry chips directly over the heat source where they can ignite and produce that beautiful, clean smoke.

Here's our quick tips from our ultimate gas grill smoking guide:

Grab a sheet of heavy-duty foil
Add ½ to 1 cup of dry wood chips
Fold it like a burrito, but leave a small opening for smoke to escape
Place it directly over your hottest burner
Wait 7-10 minutes for the smoke to start rolling

Quick safety tip: If your chips catch fire, use long grilling tongs to carefully move them to the cool side of the grill. Keep a squirt bottle with water handy to put out any flames if needed.

Quick Wood Pairing Wins:

Hickory + beef = classic BBQ flavor
Cherry + pork = beautiful color and mild sweetness
Apple + chicken/fish = perfect balance
Pecan + oak = our favorite combo that'll make charcoal folks jealous

What most people get wrong: They think any wood will do, but some impart a stronger flavor than others. Mesquite is too intense for most things (save it for Texas brisket). Maple gives subtle sweetness to almost anything. We stick with alder for planks to use for salmon. Knowing how each works will help you level up your grilling game.

Need the full breakdown? Our complete smoking wood guide has everything, including a downloadable pairing chart.

Why This Works Better Than You Think

Your gas grill gives you something charcoal can't: precise temperature control. You can maintain that perfect 225-250°F smoking zone without constantly adjusting vents or adding fuel.

Plus, with our two-zone setup (one side hot and one side cooler for ultimate control), you get clean, consistent smoke without the bitter flavors that come from temperature swings. Perfect for nailing that steak sear once you've got the smoke dialed in.

Look, we're not here to start a grill debate. Charcoal has its place, and we respect the craft. But don't let anyone tell you that your gas grill can't produce incredible, smoky flavor.

With the right tricks, your Wednesday night dinner can taste like it spent all day in a $3,000 smoker. Remember, "haters gonna hate." So, just keep doing you!

Cheers,

Kita GirlCarnivore.com
Head Meat Maven Since 2013

P.S. – Next time someone gives you grief about your gas grill, invite them over for dinner. After one bite of your gas grill smoked ribeye, they'll be asking for your secrets.

Join our Facebook page for the Weekly Roll Call.
Save your favorites to our new custom Recipe Box.
Subscribe to the new Cocktail channel - Every new subscriber helps!

Want more pro tips like this? We share our best-kept secrets three times a week. Forward this to a friend who needs better BBQ in their life.

We need your help. Have you tried a recipe on GirlCarnivore.com? Please pop over and rate the recipe ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ and leave a comment to help a future reader out.